Every year, millions of dollars, countless hours, and resources are wasted on projects that fail to deliver value, could have been achieved at a fraction of the cost, or overlooked risks. Often, the primary reason for project failure lies in the project itself—a result of poor initial idea validation or misguided objectives. These "white elephants" produce outputs that few people want, add little to no real value, or fall short of expected benefits due to unrealistic goals. In short, they lack sound business reasoning.
A thorough business idea validation process helps prevent this waste by evaluating the real value of an initiative, challenging its underlying assumptions, and determining its potential for success or failure.
Is your organization prepared to put projects through a rigorous idea validation process, even at the risk of uncovering feasibility issues or facing rejection? Explore the questions to ask and best practices for establishing a business case validation process.
Business Case Validation verifies whether an idea, project, or investment is justified. The initiative must align with business objectives, address a genuine problem, and have the potential to engage your target audience. This process helps ensure that resources are directed toward good ideas with actual value and a high likelihood of success.
Business case validation works out the kinks before wasting time and resources. It tests assumptions in real world conditions and ensures new initiatives align with an organization's goals. Early business case validation boosts decision confidence, reduces risk, and ensures the project addresses customer pain points.
Early assessment allows you to identify potential snags and refine the business plan before committing costly resources, whether it's a large startup idea or small product update. These ten steps help you define the problem and explore all options to ensure a successful project.
Start with a strong problem statement to define what is driving the project. Ask yourself: What will happen if we ignore this problem? A strong business case requires a clear understanding of the problem’s impact on potential customers, the market, and your business. For instance, if a company struggles with high customer churn, look into the long-term effects on revenue and reputation. Accurately presenting the stakes helps leadership prioritize resources.
List all assumptions about market trends, market size, prospective customer behavior, costs, and revenue projections. Validate them against historical data or industry standards, and test different scenarios (best, worst, and typical) to see how outcomes might vary. For example, with a new product launch, analyze how different adoption rates could affect revenue projections.
Evaluate all reasonable options, including doing nothing. Confirm that cost estimates and revenue projections are realistic, calculate ROI, and assess total cost of ownership (TCO) to capture full costs over time. For example, when evaluating a CRM, consider maintenance and training costs beyond the purchase price.
Check if the proposed solution is realistic regarding technology, budget, and timing, and see if it aligns with the broader business context. For example, if artificial intelligence (AI) is the aim, determine where it fits within your existing tech stack. Also, consider the impact of delays and opportunity cost: what other initiatives will not receive resources or budget if you move forward?
Gather input from stakeholders, including executives, product managers, and subject matter experts (SMEs). Their experience can help highlight suggestions that might have been missed. A CFO might flag budget risks, while sales may point out the impact on customer experience.
Identify potential risks, such as supply chain delays, and prepare and socialize mitigation and contingency plans. Knowing the risk up front helps prevent costly setbacks as you move forward.
Check that the project meets legal, regulatory, and ethical standards. For instance, when handling customer data, account for data privacy regulations to avoid legal complications.
Confirm that the project aligns with current market conditions and competitive landscape. Adjust the plan if there have been customer preference shifts or new competitor products and activities are impacting the market.
An objective review by an external expert can unearth new ideas or reveal blind spots. This brings an unbiased perspective that can enhance credibility, making it easier to gain executive support. For example, an external reviewer might notice an underestimated cost for user training when purchasing a new CRM.
Review the entire business case to ensure completeness, clarity, and consistency. Refine based on findings and feedback.
Business case validation aims to stop potential waste before committing resources. Take, for example, the Gravina Island Bridge project, also known as the "Bridge to Nowhere." It was proposed as a connection from Ketchikan, Alaska, to Gravina Island, but cancelled after extensive feedback and review.
The project was allocated $223 million in federal funds in 2005. However, after public scrutiny and years of assessment, the project was canceled in 2015, with enhanced ferry services selected as a better alternative. To prevent similar instances of potential resource misallocation, consider the following best practices as you prepare your business case validation process:
Market validation involves engaging real people in customer interviews to confirm the business idea's value, including existing and potential customers.
Recording all key assumptions about the target customer, assumptions, business model, marketing strategy, and customer needs helps keep all relevant data available throughout the validation process.
A minimum viable product (MVP) approach allows testing of the concept's appeal before committing time or costly resources.
Gathering input from external stakeholders and SMEs brings fresh perspectives that those "in the trenches" may overlook. Their unbiased insights and expertise may uncover vulnerabilities.
Business case validation is a no-brainer for evaluating the viability of projects before committing resources. Organizations can mitigate risks and maximize value by identifying and addressing potential weaknesses early. A well-executed validation process strengthens project outcomes and reinforces a culture of innovation and growth.
.avif)
.avif)
.avif)
